Round 13 v GWS: Effort v system

Considering the final margin was 49 points, it feels strange to start by commending North Melbourne’s effort.

But it’s genuinely what I believe. Sunday’s issue – in my opinion – centred around the effort being misplaced, due to the work still needed in systems, roles, and processes.

So, while these posts are usually structured chronologically, today’s going to be a little different.

What I’d like to do is show five clips illustrating effort, followed by an explanation of why the system and roles were out of balance.

Then we’ll finish with a little bit on Jason Horne-Francis.


While the North match reviews are free for all in 2022, the Shinboner Patreon is still up and running all the way through to October 31.

One day there’ll be a bunch of positives to write about, I swear. (I’m keeping this line until it happens)

It starts at $2.50 per month and goes up to $10 per month for all the benefits. As usual, a huge thank you to everyone who’s signed up.

Here are all the details and how to sign up.


If the clip doesn’t play for you, click here to view

Situation: The effort is fine from Jy Simpkin and Jason Horne-Francis. They’re trying to win the ball, and they’re putting in.

Issue: A lack of clarity in roles. With a two-on-one situation, it should be crystal clear who’s ball hunting, and who’s on Stephen Coniglio.

To steal a comment from my Twitter mentions (apologies to whoever it was), it’s Stoppages 101.

If the clip doesn’t play for you, click here to view

Situation: GWS have just won clean possession from a stoppage. Not ideal for North, but players are still chasing and working.

Issue: GWS – one of the best transition teams in the league since Mark McVeigh took the reins – have been allowed to set up with an extra behind the ball.

That extra instantly turns into an attacking weapon as soon as the Giants gain possession. All the effort in the world can’t stop weight of numbers moving at speed.

If the clip doesn’t play for you, click here to view

Situation: Flynn Perez rotates across and signals towards Lachie Whitfield as another potential danger. Perez is doing the right thing, closing up an immediate issue he sees and communicating the situation elsewhere.

Issue: While it’s partially obscured due to the broadcast angle, what’s clear is how there’s little understanding of who’s required to go towards Whitfield as the next role in the defensive chain.

Once the realisation sets in that Whitfield is the next link in the chain, it’s a half-second too late to cover. From there North battle to try and close it up, but the genie is out of the bottle.

It’s a bread and butter rotation for the better teams.


For those who have missed any posts/podcast appearances over the last week, here are links to catch up:

Friday 10th: What To Watch For: Round 13
Wednesday 8th: On the North Talk podcast
Monday 6th: From The Notebook: Round 12
Sunday 5th: North’s Round 12 Review
Friday 3rd: What To Watch For: Round 12


If the clip doesn’t play for you, click here to view

Situation: North are trying to keep the ball locked inside their forward 50 at a stoppage, although GWS have just won possession.

Issue: Harking back to the issue of a fortnight ago against St Kilda, the behind-the-ball setup is too deep.

It’s allowed Cal Ward to park in an aggressive place – and be an easy outlet via hands. The Giants exit and any chance for sustained pressure is lost.

Again, it’s easy to see the individual effort there. But it’s misplaced.

If the clip doesn’t play for you, click here to view

Situation: Tristan Xerri is caught out defending against Matt de Boer inside 50.

Issue: Tristan Xerri is forced to defend against Matt de Boer in GWS’ forward 50 (seems pretty simple).

Xerri is trying his best in a foreign role, but if there was – to repeat a phrase – clarity in roles, de Boer would have been manned by a suitable matchup at the point this clip starts.


If you’ve missed it, new features continue to be added to the Patreon-exclusive pages. A reminder:

  • For those on the $7.50 Patreon tier (or above), there’s exclusive access to the Stat Suite page, with rolling monthly stat rankings updated weekly
  • For those on the $10 Patreon tier, they have access to everything on the website, including the List Management suite – fully updated with mid-season draft additions

Here are all the details and how to sign up.


Let’s finish on a topic which has owned most of the post-match headlines: Jason Horne-Francis.

Not the high contact with Josh Kelly; that will earn him an extended bye. Instead, all the chatter about ‘frustration’ and ‘body language’ stemming from a completely normal chat with Todd Goldstein at half time.

(It was likely based around some misunderstanding at stoppages in the two minutes preceding the siren, but hard to be 100 percent certain)

There have been some comments about how it means Horne-Francis ‘isn’t invested’, ‘isn’t trying’, and all those cliches.

For me, it’s the complete opposite. Frustration means you care. This body language means you care.

In your own life, when was the last time you were angry, annoyed or despondent at something you didn’t care about?

I’d much rather this frustration rather than apathy and ‘yes sir’, ‘no sir’ type business. It’s easy to forget this is the first time Horne-Francis has experienced anything like this level of losing.

As he learns the extra level required to go from number one draft pick to star player, and when the frustration and fire is harnessed into something productive with guidance from North’s senior players, that’s when he’ll take a big step forward.

Is the current situation ideal? Of course not. Is it anything to worry about? Not at the moment, in my opinion.

Also, Horne-Francis is 18. Some responsibility when covering a teenager seems like the wise way to approach things.

2 thoughts on “Round 13 v GWS: Effort v system

  1. Great write up again Rick.
    Sitting behind the goals I was trying to figure out what changed after quarter time. In Q1 we had a zone setup for kick ins etc. An even array of players across the ground. But regularly, GWS would load one side of the ground with a couple of extra players. They would either kick to that side and/or switch once or twice to shake our zone apart.
    Particularly in the second half we seemed to match their numbers a bit better and/or play a tighter zone. Did you notice anything similar?

    1. To my eye it felt like GWS took the foot off the pedal a little bit compared to what they tried to do in the first half. Maybe I’m giving them too much credit and North not enough, but that was my read at least

Leave a Reply